New Judgment – Re E-House (China) Enterprise Holdings Limited [2026] CIGC (FSD) 100

Featured members

On 17 November 2026 the Grand Court of the Cayman Islands (Segal J) delivered its reasons for convening a single meeting of creditors and for sanctioning a scheme of arrangement under section 86 of the Companies Act (2026 Revision) proposed by E-House (China) Enterprise Holdings Limited. The Convening Order was made on 9 July 2026 and the Sanction Order on 9 October 2026. No creditor appeared to oppose at either stage. The judgment is of wider interest for its treatment of creditors who could not lawfully vote because of US sanctions, and for its analysis of whether a court which accommodates foreign sanctions in the terms of a scheme is enforcing a foreign penal or public law.

Background

The Company is a Cayman Islands exempted company listed on the Main Board of the Stock Exchange of Hong Kong. It is the holding company of a group providing real estate agency, data and related services in the PRC. Its evidence was that it was insolvent on both a cash-flow and a balance-sheet basis. This was the third Cayman scheme it had proposed for substantially the same offshore debt. Schemes sanctioned in November 2022 and November 2023 were never implemented. The first lapsed for want of cash. The second lapsed after a third party declined to release a guarantee and an underwriter withdrew.

The scheme is a full debt-for-equity swap, with no cash consideration, no new debt and no rights issue. Two series of New York-law senior notes (US$598.2 million in principal) and a Hong Kong-law convertible note of HK$1,031.9 million are released in exchange for new ordinary shares representing approximately 65% of the enlarged share capital. Creditors who acceded to the restructuring support agreement and voted in favour receive an Instruction Fee, also in shares, expected to represent approximately 5%. Existing shareholders retain approximately 30%. Professional fees and shareholder loans owed to the Company’s chairman fall outside the scheme. Kroll estimated recoveries of 0.43% to 1.63% in a liquidation, against 2.87% (neutral case) or 2.11% (adverse case) under the scheme. The scheme is inter-conditional with a parallel Hong Kong scheme, which the Court of First Instance sanctioned on 11 September 2026.

Holders of approximately 3.37% of the Notes hold through the National Settlement Depository (NSD), a Russian central securities depository. The NSD was designated by the European Union in June 2022 and, after the earlier schemes, by the United States and the United Kingdom in June 2024. The Company’s expert evidence was that, under US law, the exercise of voting rights derived from NSD-held Notes, and any facilitation of it by a US person, would breach sanctions. The scheme therefore prohibited these ‘Blocked Scheme Creditors’ from voting, deferred the cancellation of their Notes until sanctions permit, and directed their consideration into escrow, with title retained by the Company. Blocked Scheme Creditors were invited to state their views by an intention letter, to be relayed to the meeting by the chairperson, and to observe the meeting. None did either.

At the scheme meeting on 27 August 2026, 374 creditors voted, holding approximately 73% by value of all voting claims. The scheme was approved by 95.5% in number and 97.8% in value.

The decision

  • Exclusion from voting. A creditor made party to a scheme has a prima facie right to vote, as a matter of the statute, basic fairness and natural justice. Where legislation makes its voting a criminal offence, or would cause others involved in the scheme process to commit one, its inability to vote does not result from a decision of the company or from the terms of the scheme. The creditor is not given different or fewer rights under the scheme, and no class issue arises. The prohibition goes to process and to fairness ([74(b)]–[74(d)]). The Judge distinguished his decision on the 2022 scheme (E-House 1), where blocked noteholders had to be allowed to vote because their voting was not unlawful ([64]–[65]).

 

  • The Judge described himself as ‘less sanguine’ than some judges in other jurisdictions about binding creditors to a scheme on which they cannot vote ([74(a)]). The Court must ensure that any restriction on the right to vote is as limited as possible. The company should not pre-judge whether a creditor is caught by the relevant legislation. It must make reasonable efforts to ascertain the affected creditors’ views, so that they can be relayed to the meeting and taken into account at sanction. Where there is evidence that those creditors oppose the scheme, the Court should consider whether their votes would have changed the outcome ([74(e)]–[74(i)]). Those requirements were met ([74(j)]). Had the Blocked Scheme Creditors been admitted and voted against, the majority by value would still have been in the region of 94% ([109(g)]).

 

  • The exclusionary rule. The rule against the direct or indirect enforcement of a foreign penal, revenue or other public law (Dicey, Morris & Collins, 16th ed, Rule 20) did not prevent the Court from taking US sanctions law into account when giving directions for the conduct of the scheme meeting, so that US persons involved in the process were not exposed to a breach. No foreign state or its nominee sought any remedy ([69]–[71], [76]). The escrow arrangements called for a slightly different analysis, and the point was ‘not straightforward’, but the answer was the same. In both respects the scheme was structured so that it could be implemented without a breach of US sanctions. The purpose was to give effect to the scheme, and the sanctions were not being enforced by or for the benefit of the US authorities ([88]). The Judge regarded that approach as consistent with Hildyard J’s analysis of the holding period trust in Re SCUR-Alpha 1092 GmbH [2026] EWHC 2735 (Ch) at [100]–[108], handed down after the sanction hearing, and as right in both pragmatism and principle. He noted that the issue may need to be revisited in an opposed case with full argument ([105]–[108]).

 

  • No illegality. On the expert evidence the scheme could be performed without breach of the applicable sanctions. It also provides that nothing in it requires or authorises a breach, and gives the Company power to modify it to that end ([87], [111]).

 

  • Default interest. Only the convertible note carried default interest (approximately US$50.4 million, at 15%), which was excluded from scheme claims. That did not fracture the class. The question is whether the difference in treatment is so material that it would be unfair to require the two groups of creditors to vote together and be bound by each other’s decision, and the focus is on estimated recoveries in the comparator and under the scheme. The effect on recoveries was small in absolute terms, and both groups did materially better than in a liquidation. The consent of the convertible note holder was not definitive, since noteholders could still object, but carried significant weight ([53]–[55]). The Judge drew on his own decision in Hong Kong in Re Powerlong Real Estate Holdings Limited [2026] HKCFI 3836.

 

  • Instruction Fee. On first impression, 5% of the post-restructuring share capital is not de minimis, particularly where projected recoveries are very low. Materiality depends on the likely value of the shares, and in light of the Company’s financial position the Court was prepared to treat the fee as not material ([56]–[59]). At sanction the Judge pointed out that the fee had not in fact been available to Blocked Scheme Creditors, because it required a vote in favour. No such creditor had sought to accede to the restructuring support agreement or objected, and the shares had only ‘hope value’, so the difference was not material. It would have required careful consideration had a Blocked Scheme Creditor come forward ([104]).

 

  • A majority of 97.8% by value on a substantial turnout was strong evidence that an intelligent and honest creditor might reasonably approve the scheme, and the comparator confirmed it. With very low projected recoveries in a liquidation, it was rational to support the scheme for its hope value ([110(a)]–[110(b)]).

 

  • Retained equity and excluded liabilities. No absolute priority rule applies to schemes ([90]). The retention of equity by existing shareholders was fair. The chairman had undertaken to fund the costs of implementation if the Company could not, and he and the entities he controls had undertaken not to enforce their loans for three years ([110(e)]). The exclusion of professional fees and the chairman’s loans from the scheme was made in good faith and for sound commercial reasons, and had been fully disclosed ([89], [110(f)]).

 

  • International effectiveness. The Company’s expert evidence was that recognition under Chapter 15 of the US Bankruptcy Code would substantively discharge the New York-law Notes and guarantees, so that the discharge would also be recognised in the BVI, where two guarantors are incorporated and the rule in Gibbs applies ([82]–[84]). The Court was satisfied that the scheme was likely to be effective in all relevant jurisdictions ([86], [112]).

 

  • Conditions and implementation. Given the history of the earlier schemes, the Company gave specific evidence on the status of each restructuring condition, as Powerlong None of the outstanding conditions involved a cash payment, a rights issue or underwriting, a transfer of assets or the consent of a third party outside the restructuring ([113]–[115]). The Sanction Order records the Company’s undertaking to apply promptly for directions if it concludes that any condition is unlikely to be satisfied by the longstop date of 31 December 2026, and the Court retained jurisdiction over implementation ([33], [116]).

 

Adam Al-Attar KC appeared for the Company, with Nick Herrod and Ryan Hallett of Maples and Calder (Cayman) LLP.

Read the full judgment here

News you may be interested in
Events
June
South Square & RISA Bermuda Conference – 2026
South Square & RISA Bermuda Conference – 2026
South Square & RISA BVI Conference – 2026
South Square & RISA BVI Conference – 2026
South Square Digest
South Square Digest is our quarterly review of news, cases, judgments and articles covering all our practice areas.
South Square Digest
Contact us
Scroll To Top