The Cayman Islands Court of Appeal (CICA) had handed down judgment in the HQP Corporation/Direct Lending cases concerning the rights of existing and former shareholders of a company to assert claims for damages for misrepresentation in the liquidation of the company.
This concerns the “rule in Houldsworth”, which was abolished in the UK by provisions of the Companies Act. The CICA held that the rule in Houldsworth applies in the Cayman Islands to prevent existing or former shareholders who claim damages for misrepresentation against a company in liquidation from being admitted to proof in the liquidation. However, this only applies until the claims of ordinary unsecured creditors have been paid in full, with the misrepresentation claimants being entitled to prove thereafter alongside other subordinated shareholder claims.
Tom Smith KC and Annabelle Wang acted for the Liquidators in HQP Corporation and Tom Smith KC acted for the Liquidators in Direct Lending.
News you may be interested in
NEW DECISION OF THE COURT OF APPEAL – Midland Premier Properties Ltd & Anor v Doal & Ors [2026]
19/02/2026
Kira King Shortlisted for Advocate of the Year at the Women & Diversity in Law Awards 2026
11/02/2026
Judgment Hand Down: Grosvenor Property Developers Limited (in liquidation) v Portner Law Limited
02/02/2026
New Judgment – Henderson & Jones Limited v Tysers Insurance Brokers Limited [2025] EWHC 3155 (Comm)
30/01/2026
Judgment Hand Down: Grosvenor Property Developers Limited (in liquidation) v Portner Law Ltd No. 2 [2026] EWHC (Ch)
13/01/2026
Events
South Square Digest
South Square Digest is our quarterly review of news, cases, judgments and articles covering all our practice areas.


